|
Final
Report of the
Sixth International
Seminar of FORUM UNESCO - UNIVERSITY AND
HERITAGE
10 - 15 September 2001,
Polytechnic University of Valencia (Spain)
30th Anniversary of the Cultural and Natural
World Heritage Convention
in 2002,
Intensification of the Universities' Mutual
Ethical and Operational Commitment
COMMITMENTS
The Vice-Presidents, the Vice-Chancellors,
the Deans, the Directors, the professors and the
students of universities, the national Directors
of heritage from 45 countries, along with the
Representative of the United Nations Volunteers
(UNV), the Director of Programmes for the Agence
universitaire de la francophonie (450
universities, 45 countries), with the
Representatives from ICOMOS and the
International Union of Architects (IUA)
Wish to thank the authorities of the
Generalitat and of the city of Valencia for
their strong support,
Wish to congratulate the Vice-Chancellor of
the Polytechnic University of Valencia for his
remarkable and constant efforts to consolidate
the international network,
Wish to welcome ICOMOS' decision to sign an
agreement with Forum UNESCO – University and
Heritage and, in so doing, to associate actively
the international network in the next General
Assembly of ICOMOS in 2002 in Zimbabwe,
Remark, with acute interest, the intention of
the International Union of Architects (IUA) to
develop with Forum UNESCO - University and
Heritage a curriculum on heritage intervention
for architects,
Rejoice over the increasing spontaneous
mobilisation of other universities, particularly
those from countries joining the network for the
first time, like Chile, Japan, Poland, Puerto
Rico, the United Kingdom and Uruguay,
Value the progress made thanks to the
developments of the network at a national level
and the participation of three universities in
each of the following countries: Algeria,
Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Colombia, Italy
Lebanon and Spain,
Rejoice over the active involvement of
several young professors and thirty or so
students from the universities of Colombia,
Cuba, Italy, Japan, Romania and Spain,
Remark, with acute interest, the Polytechnic
University of Valencia's publication of the 120
activities and projects achieved by Forum UNESCO
– University and Heritage since 1996 along
with the synopses of the 112 papers received for
the Sixth international Seminar including those
from universities which did not take part in the
seminar but still showed their interest,
Notice, through the 69 scientific and
technical papers given by the participants, the
progress of an efficient co-operation between
national heritage practitioners and the
universities,
Value the commitment of the Spanish media (newspapers,
radios and TV channels) in favour of the
protection of the cultural and natural world
heritage,
Decide with a view to consolidate the
structural frame of the network, to rationalise
and intensify its action after five years of
existence and at the beginning of a new phase
coinciding with the Thirtieth Anniversary of the
World Heritage Convention:
I. To Restructure the working mechanisms
of the international network in order to
increase its capacity for co-ordination,
mobilisation, action and sharing, by
u
the signature of a Pact of Universities
by the Vice-Chancellors of the universities of
Forum UNESCO- University and Heritage in order
to involve their institutions on an official
level and give them the necessary means to meet
the goals of the network. The completion of the
Pact between the universities will be undertaken
in close co-operation with ICCROM, ICOMOS, ICOM,
IUA and IFLA,
u
the constitution of a working group
under the supervision of UNESCO, whose task will
consist in orientating the network and grant the
label and logo of Forum UNESCO- University and
Heritage to the projects (especially if
operational) for the safeguard of heritage,
u
the constitution of thematic working
groups within the network, such as :
- cultural and natural world heritage,
- urban-planning
and heritage,
- archaeological
sites and museums,
- youth and
heritage,
- heritage
for reconciliation,
- intangible
heritage,
- promotion, awareness-raising and communication
on heritage,
- heritage and new technologies.
II. To intensify the rallying projects in
2002 in order to celebrate the Thirtieth
Anniversary in a concrete and useful way. The
priority will go to activities revolving around
training, awareness raising, promotion and
mobilisation in favour of the natural and
cultural as well as the tangible and intangible
World Heritage.
International Activities and Projects
1. International Symposium entitled
"Heritage and the Media", University
of Laval, Quebec, Canada, organised in September
2002, with a double view to raise
the population and the international community's
awareness of the issues of heritage, research
and raise issues on this theme,
2. International Seminar of Forum UNESCO -
University and Heritage, University of Yarmuk,
Jordan, organised in the ancient Greco-Roman
city of Irbil and on the World Heritage site of
Petra in November 2002, on the theme: "The
protection of World Heritage and Cultural
Tourism".
3. Creation of an international committee of
students from Forum UNESCO - University and
Heritage, University of Waseda, Japan, in 2002,
4. Virtual Meeting on the Internet,
University of Waseda, Japan: Exchanges of
theoretical and practical knowledge between
students from the above university and students
from the Polytechnic University of Valencia,
Spain, in 2002.
5. Second Cycle of workshops for the
exchanges of theoretical and practical knowledge
for university professors and specialists on the
themes of the management and use of heritage and
of the methodology used in historical centres.
The first cycle of workshops focussed on Requena
(Spain), Torino (Italy) and Porto (Portugal). In
2002, the workshop number III will focus on
Salvador de Bahia (Brazil) and Bogota (Colombia).
In 2003, it will focus on Beirut (Lebanon) and
Buenos Aires (Argentina).
6. Launching of an international drawing/photography
contest, in order to raise awareness amongst the
youth, about the cultural and natural world
heritage, and the tangible and intangible
heritage. This project is a collaboration
between the network of the Associated Schools of
UNESCO and the universities.
Projects and Activities in Africa
7. National Symposium of Archaeologists
organised by the University of Benin, Togo, and
to be held in December 2001.
8. Workshop of the universities of Western
Africa on the theme "Heritage, Tourism and
Development", organised by the Agence
universitaire de la francophonie and the
University Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar (Senegal) and
to be held from 23 to 27 January 2002.
9. Meeting of the African universities of
Forum UNESCO - University and Heritage,
organised by Forum UNESCO - University and
Heritage and the University of Benin, Togo, with
the financial support of the Polytechnic
University of Valencia (Spain), and to be held
in 2002. Consolidation of the network in Africa
and identification of the actions to be given
priority and of projects undertaken in a
collaboration between two or more instances.
Projects and Activities in Latin America and
the Caribbean
10. Study on project for conservation
and sustainable development on the Island of
Carex (Tierrabomba, Colombia), in the Bay of
Cartagena de Indias. Study undertaken by the
students of the Polytechnic University of
Valencia (Spain), in collaboration with the
University Jorge Tadeo Lozana and the University
Rafael Nuñez (Colombia).
11. Mobilisation of a group of students for
the setting up of a heritage inventory and for
awareness raising about the value of local
heritage. Organised by the University of
Quisqueya (Haiti) in 2002.
12. Seminar of the role of universities in
training and communication about Heritage and in
the preservation of this heritage. Workshop
involving students through an exhibition and a
contest, organised by the University of Buenos
Aires (Argentina), from the 1st
to the 7th
of September 2002.
13. Practical workshop for teachers and
students on the World Heritage sites of the
Jesuit Missions in Argentina. Organised by the
University of Vera Cruz (Mexico), the
Polytechnic University of Valencia (Spain) and
ICOMOS Argentina, and to be held in 2002.
14. Classes for teachers about the
conservation of heritage, in Cartagena de Indias
(Colombia), organised by the University Jorge
Tadeo Lozana (Colombia), the University Rafel
Nuñez (Colombia), the Parcarex Foundation, the
Public Works Company of Cartagena de Indias (Colombia),
and by the Polytechnic University of Valencia (Spain).
To be held in the first semester of 2002.
15. Workshops and classes on the
architectural heritage of Bogota, Tunja and
Villa de Leyva (Colombia), organised by the
University of Santo Tomas, the Mayor of Villa de
Leyva (Colombia) and the Polytechnic University
of Valencia (Spain). To be held in the first
semester of 2002.
16. Doctoral classes in Santiago de Cuba,
funded by the Polytechnic University of Valencia
(Spain).
17. Restoration workshop of the Forts of the
Caribbean Route in San Juan de Puerto Rico in
July 2002. Organised by the University of Vera
Cruz (Mexico), the Polytechnic University of
Valencia (Spain), the University of Puerto Rico
and the National Park Site.
18. Restoration workshop of the Fort
of San Salvador de La Punta (La Havana, Cuba)
with Cuban students doing a Masters in heritage.
19. Workshop for the observation of the local
colonial heritage (Sugar cane factories) with
teachers and students from the Department of
Architecture, University Quisqueya (Haiti),
organised in the framework of the "The
Slave Route" programme of UNESCO.
20. Publication of the work and
results obtained in the workshop started in
December 2000 in Cartagena de Indias (Colombia).
21. Cycle of conferences on the architectural
heritage organised by the Trade Chamber of
Commerce of Rosario (Argentina) the Trade Stock
Exchange of Valencia (Spain) and in
collaboration with the University of Rosario
(Argentina).
22. Creation of a UNESCO Chair in heritage
management, with an emphasis on
pluridisciplinary approaches, University of
Buenos Aires (Argentina).
Projects and Activities in Asia and the Pacific
23. Workshop with the universities of Asia
organised by Deakin University (Australia), in
co-operation with the University of Hue (Viet
Nam) and to be held in 2002.
24. Workshop for the education of the
national practitioners of Asian countries about
awareness - raising, promotion and communication
organised by Deakin University (Australia), and
to be held in 2002.
Projects and Activities in the Arab States
25. International on-site work camps for
specific safeguarding actions of the heritage of
Tlemcen (Algeria).
26. Post-graduate classes on the built
heritage for local executives, engineers and
professional from the Construction Industry.
Organised by the University Abu Bekr El Kaid of
Tlemcen (Algeria).
27. Revitalisation of a profession through
classes on zellidj, a technique used on
monuments, and organised by the University Abu
Bekr El Kaid of Tlemcen (Algeria).
28. National Campaign for awareness raising
and for the mobilisation of resources through an
exhibition and conferences about completed
restoration projects focussing on the World
Heritage ancient site of the City of Damascus (Syrian
Arab Republic). Organised by the University of
Damascus (Syrian Arab Republic) in 2002.
Projects and Activities in Europe and North
America
29. Heritage interdisciplinary studies:
development of studies within the framework of
existing programmes and disciplines or according
to personalised arrangements in order to do a
Masters or a doctorate overlapping several
disciplines. Elaboration of international
agreements in favour of student mobility (internships,
scholarships, inter-university exchanges, etc.).
Organised by the University of Laval, Quebec
(Canada).
30. Series of activities and projects
elaborated by students, focussing on the
heritage of medium-sized cities and to be
undertaken in a progressive manner over the year
2002. Organised by the University of Luisiada
(Portugal).
31. Development of a global concept and of
local applications for the practical
training about professional knowledge and its
modern uses (structure and management with
partners), pre-project, University of Laval,
Quebec (Canada).
32. Virtual Institute and circulating
inventory: project undertaken with a view to
establish infrastructures for the circulation of
knowledge through the dissemination of archives,
documentation on heritage, and the creation of
an international network for electronic
exchanges enabling direct access to data bases
and research works whose access is normally
restricted, University of Laval, Quebec
(Canada).
33. Virtual conservation of the endangered
religious heritage: project on the electronic
safeguard of heritage whose physical protection
seems difficult or impossible. This project aims
at the theoretical development and
experimentation in the field of religious
heritage with a first emphasis put on the
French-speaking Protestants' heritage of Quebec,
University of Laval, Quebec (Canada).
34. Project for the restoration by Students
of the Synagogues from the Centre of Izmir (Turkey).
Organised by the Department of Architecture,
University of Dokus Eylül (Turkey) and the
Belazel Academy of Arts and Design, Jerusalem (Israel),
summer 2002.
35. Project for the
development of Public Participation in the
revitalization and conservation Project for the
Kemeralti City Centre in Izmir (Turkey),
University of Dokuz Eylül, Faculty of
Architecture, with the collaboration of the two
local governments (mayors), the Governor's
Office and the Chambers of Architects and
Planners.
36. Project for the creation of a UNESCO
Chair for the enhancement of World Heritage and
the reinforcement of its economic role,
University of Yash (Romania).
37. Research project on the boxed ceiling of
the "Sala Daurada" of the old town
hall of Valencia, sponsored by the Polytechnic
University of Valencia (Spain).
38. Research project on geophysics applied to
Turkey, in collaboration with the Institute for
Architectural Research, Venice (Italy).
39. Second international archaeological study
of Forum UNESCO – University and Heritage, to
be held in Valencia (Spain) in July 2002, and
organised and sponsored by the Polytechnic
University of Valencia (Spain).
FINAL REPORT
The nine plenary meetings and the 14
workshops of the Sixth international Seminar of
Forum UNESCO – University ad Heritage, held in
Valencia from the 10th
to the 15th
of September 2001, completed their agendas.
This meeting lasted for six days, the first
day being devoted to the inauguration of the
Seminar with the official presentation of the
authorities involved and of the associated
international organisations. The second day was
devoted to workshops focusing on the evaluation,
with the participants, of the activities of the
past five years and especially on registering
the participants' impressions of the
organisation. The second day ended with a debate.
Then, in the three intense days that followed,
the scientific and technical programme of this
meeting was elaborated. Various themes were
discussed in-depth and with enthusiasm.
This session was followed by a plenary
meeting devoted to examining the structure, the
working mechanism and the action of our budding
network. A formal list of commitments and
activities for 2002 was born out of this meeting
and is to be found in the first part of this
report.
The schedule of this Seminar also included a
cultural programme over three evenings with a
show, a concert, a historical visit and the
lighting of a "falla" realised for and
by Forum UNESCO – University and Heritage.
The preliminary documents for the Seminar are
attached to the present report, namely:
-the programme,
-the publication of the 118 synopses or
summaries of the papers,
-the list of participants.
Monday 10 September 2001
Opening session
Mr. Justo NIETO NIETO, Vice-Chancellor of the
Polytechnic University of Valencia (Spain) and
President of Forum UNESCO – University and
Heritage, registered, in his speech, the global
understanding of heritage and the ensuing
holistic approach.
Mr. Jean-Dominique ASSIE, Director of
Programmes for the Agence universitaire de la
francophonie, recalled the great principles of
freedom and universality conveyed by the
university as a social institution. He
officially announced the organisation of two
Forum UNESCO – University and Heritage
workshops, the first one with Western African
universities in Dakar in 2002 and the second one
with South-East Asian universities.
Then, Ms Marcela MIRO PEREZ, President of the
Cortes de la Generalitat de Valencia, insisted
on the citizens' responsibility to pass on the
heritage they have through values which should
be considered as part of the intangible heritage.
As for Mr. Mounir BOUCHENAKI, Assistant
Director-General for Culture of UNESCO and
Representative of the Director-General of
UNESCO, he emphasised the ethical role of
universities regarding heritage through their
academic authority and their scientific
discipline. He insisted on the necessity for
pluridisciplinary dialogue in order to develop
and enrich knowledge and consolidate the
network.
Plenary session: Targets, realisations and
perspectives of the network
The ICOMOS reinforces its partnership with
Forum UNESCO by announcing an agreement in a
letter of mutual understanding.
The ICOM, in spite of its unconditional
support for the Seminar, could not deliver its
message, which we know to have been very
positive.
Then, about the chapter concerning training,
the International Union of Architects (IUA)
wishes to work along with Forum UNESCO for the
setting-up of criteria defining the methodology
to be adopted by architects in the field of
heritage work.
Eventually, the United Nations Volunteers (UNV)
gave us a message of hope through a film on the
experience of a Japanese volunteer's passion for
the safeguard of Honduras heritage.
The second part of this session focused on
the renewed commitment of first plan partners
from the universities which had organised the
preceding Seminars of the Forum UNESCO network.
They expressed their aims and told us about
their achievements and about their plans for the
future.
As for the Institut du patrimoine culturel
(IPAC) of the University Laval, Québec
(Canada), which prides itself on being a place
for concertation and co-ordination, it announced
its three-fold plan of action about training,
research and the organisation of scientific
activities.
The UNESCO Heritage Chair at the University
of Laval, Quebec (Canada) follows a pro-active
approach which is trans-disciplinary,
inter-collegial and international. The
activities of this Chair are devoted to the
heritage of local communities while trying to
associate modernity and heritage.
The UNESCO Heritage Chair at Deakin
University, Melbourne (Australia), defined its
five main targets. During this year, this Chair
set up a trans-disciplinary programme about
heritage. This programme attracts students from
the entire Asia-Pacific area.
The University of Al Akhawayn, Ifrane (Morocco),
located nearby World Heritage sites, devotes
itself to the cultural and economic development
of the area through four projects which have
already been launched.
And, finally, the Lebanese American
University of Byblos (Lebanon) is convinced that
the law remains the basis of any heritage
intervention. Youth and the media should become
privileged partners in this development.
Tuesday 11 September 2001
Plenary session: Thirtieth Anniversary of the
natural and cultural World Heritage Convention
The UNESCO states once more the aims of this
sixth meeting held with the thirtieth
anniversary of the 1972 Convention in mind. The
UNESCO also emphasises the importance of the
ideas of exchange, sharing and civil
responsibility especially in relation to local
heritage as the privileged locus for
awareness-raising in society in general.
It is also worth saying that Forum UNESCO,
gathered in a plenary session on that day, was
deeply shocked, like the rest of the world, by
the news of the terrorist attack on symbolic USA
landmarks. The participants were appalled by
this incredible news and, following a suggestion
from the Vice-Chancellor of the Polytechnic
University of Valencia (Spain), Mr NIETO NIETO,
they observed five minutes of silence in
solidarity with the families affected.
"Benchmarking" group dynamic
The Polytechnic University of Valencia (Spain)
required the services of a team specialised in a
group dynamic technique called "Benchmarking".
This technique focuses on group learning of
diagnoses and solutions by listing encountered
problems, selecting the most difficult ones and
thinking together about innovative solutions.
The participants, divided into three
linguistic workshops, identified a number of
problems encountered within the Forum UNESCO –
University and Heritage network. Among these,
let us consider the poor dissemination of
information, the too large or too general aims
of the meetings, the insufficient presence of
students and the lack of a balanced geographical
representation in the network. Besides, the lack
of inter-university and inter-institutional co-operation
at this stage of our development is to be
regretted.
Moreover, problems linked to the working
mechanism of the network, to the content of
meetings, to the under-use of available
electronic instruments and to a lack of funding
for projects have been identified.
Eventually, we stated once again the
necessity for even more direct contacts along
with the use of new information technologies and
for an in-depth evaluation of the work already
completed within the network.
Plenary session: conclusions to "benchmarking"
As a conclusion to "benchmarking",
other problems brought up in the morning came up
again, for example: the necessary priority that
should be given to student participants in our
activities, the horizontal dynamic of the
organisation and the subsequent lack of
inter-regional contacts, insufficient exchanges
between members and the difficulty in fostering
a feeling of belonging.
Besides, the need to produce information
material on the structure and working mechanism
of the network and the need to constitute an
international committee representing the
different components of the network and in
charge of the definition of a technical,
scientific and ethical short plan were brought
up. Moreover, this instance for dialogue would
enable the existence of the projects on the long
run and the consistence of the network's
actions. Besides, the universities are aware of
their innumerable human resources, mainly
students, who constitute an amazing yet
under-used force of action.
Wednesday 12 and Thursday 13 September 2001
were devoted to our technical and scientific
programme
Youth and Heritage
The universities acknowledge the rich
potential of students, whether in Brazil, Cuba,
Italy, Lebanon or Spain. The involvement of the
youth on numerous sites is part of an
educational action undertaken by the university
in addition to being a lesson in good
citizenship for the community directly involved
but also for society as a whole.
This type of safeguard work camp offering an
integrated curriculum concerns students of
course but unfortunately it does not involve
youth outside the academic institution.
Therefore the sites of Forum UNESCO should mix
students and non-studying youths as much as
possible and stand thus as a factor for social
development.
Finally, the universities should have a duty
to remember the political changes of our times
so that the youth does not loose the sense of
history and heritage.
Architectural Heritage
The papers in this field were very dense and
varied, hence the somehow heterogeneous quality
of the ideas developed below.
The increasing contribution of the most
advanced scientific techniques (for example,
geo-radar, chemical and physical analyses of
stone, earthenware and mortar) to the safeguard
of the architectural heritage was pointed out.
The use of air-photography as an instrument
of comparison about the environmental evolution
of heritage seems particularly fruitful.
Concrete safeguarding projects were presented
as educational tools, individually, in detail
and with a particular emphasis on the adopted
methodology.
The creation of a Centre for anthropological
and ethnological studies on black Colombian
culture was announced.
Original rehabilitations of the twentieth
century heritage were presented: warehouses or
railway stations were turned into universities
or museums. The need to give priority to the
safeguard of contemporary heritage was
reasserted once more. Other projects focus on
the maintenance of the original functions of
local buildings like public baths (hammam) or
social housing, which can raise the awareness of
heritage in the general public.
The role of the State as a partner in the
preservation of historical buildings was
criticised, as it cannot be the only one
responsible for this mission. A heritage
protective legal system effectively implemented
is the only way to solve the dilemma of the
choice between the State or the private property.
Finally, the following idea was emphasised:
the end purpose of safeguarding heritage is to
protect human beings, which are themselves part
of the cosmic heritage inseparable from its
environment.
Heritage and the media
To begin with, the problem of the access to
sufficiently documented information was brought
up. It is worth noticing that newspapers, as
part of the media, mirror public awareness and
life in society with its unending changes. Hence
newspapers are the memory of society and thus
should become, as archives, an information
source for the restoration of heritage.
Besides, it is impossible to dissociate
natural and cultural heritage. In fact heritage
can be defined increasingly as part of the
global concept of life. That is why information
agents must consider mankind in relation with
its environment. An important question arises
then: do the media contribute, whether in a
conscious or unconscious way, to the
transformation of the impact of the media into
collective hallucination?
Do they promote a cause. Do they raise an
awareness in the general public? These are other
aspects of the question. The use of a
sensational form or content only focussing on
minor elements of a situation is tempting for
the media.
Only the professional ethic of journalists
can resist this regrettable propensity.
There is sometimes a contradiction, and
sometimes even a conflict, between an intangible
cultural heritage standing for certain values
and the defence of elements from the threatened
natural heritage. In this context, the media
could act as mediators.
Eventually, Forum UNESCO could act as a
source of information and as an education tool
for the media wishing to be more closely
associated with the network's activities.
Heritage and civil engineering
In a situation of danger, a traditional and
outdated equipment can become a protection for
the concerned heritage sites. This is why civil
engineering, if serving heritage through methods
for quality evaluation, enables, for instance,
the study of the behaviour of stone ruins
exposed to repeated earth tremor. Hence,
engineering, with its pluridisciplinary approach,
can also contribute to the safeguard of the
material heritage.
Industrial heritage
Since industry has conquered our time and
space, the very notion of heritage came up in
relation to industry.
Since the nineteenth century a new way to
teach within an industrial environment with a
didactic approach and an original understanding
of the industrial landscapes, has come up, for
instance in the area of Valencia.
However, Mankind, although it has witnessed
the tremendous transformations of its
environment due to industrial development,
remains the central element and also the main
force of these transformations.
Eventually, although the industrial heritage
and chiefly the iron and steel industrial
heritage appeared through human intervention, it
also exists from the exploitation of natural
resources to the transformation of these
resources, thanks to its geographical and
geophysical context.
Similarly the transport and the exportation
are enabled by a favourable physical environment.
Moreover, social life has often been
radically transformed and should be understood
for what it is and in its globality. In this
context, social themes should really enter in
consideration when tackling questions about
industrial heritage.
Pictorial and sculptural heritage
Because of the lack of time, the session for
papers on this theme had to be cancelled in
agreement with the authors of the papers who
were aware that their papers would be published
in the proceedings of this sixth Seminar anyway.
Heritage and law
As it is often said, "there can be no
education without culture". Similarly,
there cannot be any culture without heritage.
Nowadays we can go even further and state that
there cannot be any viable heritage without an
appropriate legislation.
Besides, heritage, and especially cultural
heritage, can be the victim of a badly drafted
legislation. The law is therefore a double-sided
tool that has to be used with competence in
order to avoid irreparable losses.
In spite of the progress in raising the
awareness of the populations about heritage, one
has to remain careful because public authorities
could take an unfair advantage of their power in
the field of heritage.
Heritage and environment
The presence of nature and the environmental
context have to be taken into account on a
global scale in all heritage interventions. The
methods of rural economy such as econometry can
be used to evaluate the size of a heritage site,
whether it is cultural or natural. Geomorphology
along with cartography also help studying the
physical environment as a whole. Beyond
quantitative methods, quality analysis enables a
better understanding of the landscape heritage.
Therefore we can state once again, as we did
in the introduction to these workshops, that
heritage should be considered in its global
dimension and therefore, only a holistic
approach associating culture and nature can be
scientifically acceptable.
Museology and academic museums
In the context of the universities,
inter-institutional co-operation projects seem
to be starting worldwide and Forum UNESCO,
through the ICOM Committee of academic museums (the
tangible result of their co-operation) is
particularly aware of this new trend. Indeed,
universities from the Northern Hemisphere join
universities from the Southern Hemisphere to
carry out their museographical projects. Whether
in Africa or in Central America, the effects of
this new phenomenon can be observed.
Something else can be observed: the
association of some universities with museums in
order to set up their educational programmes and
in the long run to increase the understanding
and appreciation for elements of close local
heritage.
Tourism and management of cultural heritage
The main issue, with a process for the
enhancement of heritage at a municipal level, is
the involvement of the local population to this
wide enterprise. The keys to successful local
development lie in the increase of the
attractive value of a place and in the
improvement of the quality of the structures
welcoming the visitors in a tourist site.
Besides the success of this operation lies
the involvement of the population with the
transformations concomitant to a better cultural
offer. Local decision-makers must take into
account the population's interest and its wish
to open up for tourism development.
In this context, educating the people becomes
a fundamental part of heritage management.
Thematic cartography is also a choice tool
for developing tourism activities in relation
with heritage management.
Intangible heritage
Sharing a culture with the greatest number of
people does not necessarily mean focusing on
ostensibly visible cultural signs. Ways of
living also convey important cultural values.
For example, food or medicine cannot find a
place in this theoretical framework. However,
the publication of intangible forms in the book,
disk, CD-Rom format, etc. often remains the best
way to keep a trace of them.
In terms of the preservation of cultural
heritage, we have to say that the means and the
raw materials are plenty whereas age-long
traditional knowledge is lacking. Hence any
national endeavour for the safeguard of the
built heritage should go along with the
preservation of traditional professions.
Besides the restoration of the built heritage
can sometimes entail the revitalisation of
age-old traditions and becomes hence a factor
for the regeneration of these traditions.
Moreover, the oral heritage like universal
tales and legends is beyond the space and time
of all cultures and sometimes fixes itself in
written literature. This oral heritage is also
an excellent tool for exploring cultures,
opening up to others and of course developing a
culture of peace.
General remarks on the scientific and
technical programme
Out of all the interventions in this
scientific and technical programmes, 69 papers
were given. Out of these, 45 came from Spanish
speaking universities and 25 came directly from
the Polytechnic University of Valencia. It goes
without say that the proportion of papers is
unusual for an international meeting.
Beside one has to salute the immense efforts
of the Polytechnic University of Valencia to
mobilise so many academic resources on the theme
of heritage, especially in the context of this
dense national concentration. The efforts of
this university, its intense activity in the
past five years and its numerous research works
and publications on the theme of heritage should
also be saluted.
The increasing involvement of students in
this Seminar should also be mentioned. In
addition, the presence of national delegations,
representing much more than just one institution
and in fact standing for a group of universities
working on this mobilising theme, should be
pointed out and they should be thanked for their
outstanding work.
Friday 14 September 2001
Plenary session: the XXXth Anniversary of the
World Heritage Convention (2002):
Mobilisation of human, technical and financial
resources
The network giving immediate priority to the
signature in 2002 of a Pact of universities, the
creation of a dialogue Committee or an advisory/orientation
Committee, with the most active universities in
the network. Priority is also given to the
organisation of international Seminars on a
single and precise theme. The membership to the
Pact and Committee should also include the
central headquarters and the UNESCO chairs while
respecting the geographical distribution.
Forum UNESCO - University and Heritage should
become the instance to which the universities
could go to seek help in the emerging field of
heritage.
The network should also seek to lower the
existing differences between universities,
between those that have some experience in the
field of heritage and those that have less
experience or those who cannot afford such means.
CONSISTENCY, CONTINUITY AND CONCERTATION
are the key words of this meeting. Indeed,
the universities involved in the heritage
management under Forum UNESCO - University and
Heritage should, in their own interest, work
together with a consistent approach and with a
view to continuity through a flexible but
helpful structure for all our activities for
education, research and publicity about heritage.
Of course, this should be done in a spirit of
mutual help and sharing.
Plenary session: Projects and
activities of Forum UNESCO - University and
Heritage: for an impulse and the implementation
of the World Heritage Convention on the occasion
of its Thirtieth Anniversary: Proposals
submitted by the universities.
Numerous projects were announced by
universities listed along with the commitments.
Thank you very much for the collaboration of
the sessions' chairpersons. We also wish to
thank Marielle Richon, from the UNESCO
Headquarters, for her help in drafting this
report.
Philippe Dubé
Professor, Université Laval (Canada)
General Rapporteur
Saturday 15 September 2001
|