| The EFA 2000 Assessment: Country Reports | ||
| Marshall Islands |
Part I: Descriptive Section
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The report was produced by Dr. Falairiva Taafaki, Special Adviser to the Minister of Education of the Marshall Islands, and Mr Patrick Langmoir, Under Secretary for Primary and Secondary education.
In the process of producing this report special recognition is due to the Minister of Education of the Marshall Islands, the Honourable Justin de Brum, whose support of the work of UNESCO and Education for All 2000 Assessment has been consistent throughout.
That this work is able to reach its final stage is due to the persistent effort of UNESCO, Apia, and its Support Team which included Mrs Celia Barelle and Mrs Ada Pannett.
Special thanks to Mrs Edna Tait, Director of UNESCO Apia, for her continued support and inspiring guidance which enabled the final assembling of this report.
Thanks are also extended to the members of the Pacific RTAG Group for their assistance and support.
A final word must, however, must be said on the contribution of Mrs Ada Pannett to the report . The meticulous organisation of the document and the professional guidance that went into the report is appreciated.
INTRODUCTION
The Republic of the Marshall Islands consists of thirty-three atoll islands spread over one million square kilometres of ocean. Such a vast expanse of ocean poses logistical implications for the management of education and its delivery. Historically, the Marshall Islands had a series of political suitors including the Germans and the Japanese before it became a United States Trust Territory after World War II. The Marshall Islands gained political independence in 1979 and in 1986 entered into a fifteen year Compact of Free Association with the United States - an arrangement that covered both economic and security obligations. The Republic of the Marshall Islands is an active member of the international community, becoming a full member of the United Nations in 1984 and thereafter WHO, UNESCO and the UNDP. In the Pacific region, the Republic of the Marshall Islands is a member of the South Pacific Forum, the Pacific Community and the University of the South Pacific.
The Republic of the Marshall Islands has a population of approximately 55,000 and a birth-rate of 4%, making it the highest in the Pacific region, and which raises enormous problems for education and for human resources planning. The existing capability of Head Start Program to expand its enrolment for example nowhere meets the rapidly increasing pre-school population. Unless substantial and dramatic approaches are adopted the problems for education in the very near future will grow deeper and more complex. Of the 55,000 population, 50 % are concentrated in the two main urban towns of Majuro and Ebeye
The Republics economy is artificially sustained through aid and support from the United States and other donor communities. Efforts to increase the productivity of the private sector are strongly supported by Government through the creation of favourable policies and incentives. To date the Government continues to be the largest employer although there are strenuous efforts to reduce the Civil Service work force. Retraining programmes designed to prepare a large number of Civil Servants to fit into the Private Sector are ongoing.
The Compact of Free Association with the United States allows for free access to Marshallese to enter and reside in the mainland United States. This pattern of migration appears to be increasing as the future of the Compact draws near the year 2001. No study has been been conducted to date to determine what the possible implications are of this migration on the future of the country.
The traditional economy is based on rural farming and agricultural activities, but the level of production has been strictly subsistence. Production of copra, the only cash crop in the country could not be increased although the price has been at its all time high, the reason being that there is not enough shipping to transport copra from the main production areas- the outer islands. Effort by government to decentralise wherever possible certain functions of education, health, economic development is steady but slow.
An influential phenomenon that is affecting the whole sphere of national development in the island nations of the Pacific, including the Marshall Islands, is the fact that these nations are increasingly becoming part of a larger process that is taking place in the region. Alliances, whether political, economic or security are continuously being forged. The process of regional integration appears to be quite irreversible. Public reforms, for example, is a requirement of the economic model proposed by the Asian Development Bank and adopted by some members of the South Pacific Forum. These requirements are in part set upon by donor communities as conditions for their support of national development in small island nations. Criteria for economic support such as accountability are a part of this larger process. Island nations are grouping together to strengthen their position on environmental and fisheries issues. Similar patterns appear to be developing with respect to education. Academic performances of the Republic of the Marshall Islands public primary schools are now assessed using the PILL test, which is a test designed for Grade 4 in primary schools of a number of countries in the region. The possibility is therefore, that a regional curriculum framework for primary schools in the region cannot be ruled out. If this happen, countries like the Republic of the Marshall Islands may have to review their budgetary appropriation for primary school education.
PART 1- Background
1. EFA GOALS AND TARGETS
National Plans /EFA Plans
A number of national efforts commissioned to review education in the country included the Report of the Education Committee of 1984, the Master Ten Year Plan of 1989 -1999, Education Conference of 1990 and the National Economic and Social Summit of 1996. These discussed the need for an educational system that is thorough and efficient, and were designed to help develop childrens capacity for self-reliance. National plans or initiatives to promote education in the Marshall Islands at whatever level, have adopted this philosophical vision, which found itself incorporated as the cornerstone of the Education Act of 1991 ( P.L. 1991-125). The aim of education, as stated, was to prepare children of the Republic of the Marshall Islands to become self-reliant individuals and to function socially, politically, and economically in society.
(i). Early Childhood Education
Goals:
Since 1990, however, the Head Start Program in the Marshall Islands has developed to the point where it could establish long term goals, prominent among which are:
To incrementally expand pre-school enrolment over a ten year period until it is able to cater for at least 50% of pre-school children in the county.
This goal was especially made urgent by the mounting pressure brought about by the high birth rate in the Republic of the Marshall Islands.
To ensure that Head Start program is accessible to children from socially and economically disadvantaged families, including young single mothers.
The idea was to make pre-school education accessible to all children regardless of their social and economic background.
To expand the number of outer island Head Start centres and to increase the enrolment of existing centres to ensure that all children living in the rural sector benefit from Early Childhood Development programs.
About 45% to 50% of the children of pre-school going age resided in outer islands of the Republic. Expansion of enrolment and establishment of new centres would help enhance the ability of outer islands to accommodate more pre-school children.
To strengthen teacher training programs through collaboration with training agencies such as the University of the South Pacific and PREL.
The importance of well-trained teachers at the pre-school level was considered to be critical. Their availability in adequate number was just as important in order to ensure that the recognised pupil-teacher ratio was achieved and maintained.
To foster an active and ongoing joint working relationship with non-governmental organisations running pre-school programs.
The relationship was ad-hoc at the time and was confined to children of non-governmental organisations using Head Start recreational facilities or officials of both programs getting together for social activities. Structuring an arrangement in which both parties could benefit from shared learning experiences or programs would give the relationship a deeper meaning.
To strengthen the relationship between Head Start and the parent community. This is already the hallmark of the Head Start program. However, Head Start had hoped to secure the voluntary services of parents with special or recognised skills, to encourage the support of the private sector, and to work together with parents over issues important to the operation of the Head Start program.
To securing a stable long term financial base.
Given the uncertainties surrounding United States funding and the future of the Compact, exploring and securing guaranteed sources of funding for pre-school education in the Republic of the Marshall Islands was considered to be of the utmost importance.
(ii). Primary
Goals:
To make primary education the national standard for all citizens of the Republic of the Marshall Islands and concentrate available resources on strengthening primary education before all else.
This was based on the belief that primary education would probably continue in the foreseeable future to be the only formal schooling that half of the population would receive. It should therefore be pursued as the priority area for investment of the Republic of the Marshall Islands limited resources.
To make a significant shift from central administration to local administration of primary schools in order to encourage and enable local communities to assume a greater share of the responsibility for oversight, maintenance and improvement of their schools.
Local ownership of the schools was considered a critical factor in achieving improvement goals for the primary schools. Long range educational reforms in the primary education would not be realised if local communities did not have a central responsibility for their own schools.
To establish a revised system of financing primary schools whereby annual subsidies on a per capita enrolment basis are offered to local communities to cover a substantial part of the cost of maintaining and operating primary schools, with additional funds provided when necessary for building construction and other capital costs.
Communities would need some initial basic support as they build their capacity to augment more fully the subsidies provided by government.
To launch a pilot program to institute a community based governance system at six or eight schools selected on the basis of their readiness to serve as model schools.
This was viewed as a substantial change in the management of primary schools. It was designed to give local governments the opportunity to build their capacity to administer and to manage public schools in their jurisdictions.
To revise the role of the Ministry of Education from direct administration of all primary schools to one of providing national leadership and incentives to encourage local communities to develop and operate improved schools and to strive to achieve national goals and serve in the best interest of the Republic. The role of the Ministry of Education would focus on:
Standards: to develop and promulgate a set of minimum standards for the establishment and operation of primary schools.
Evaluation: to establish a system of evaluating the performance of primary schools managed by local communities and to conduct national standards and achievement tests.
Support: to develop new capabilities to support the efforts of communities and the needs of schools under their care in areas such as teacher training, recruitment and curriculum development.
To establish limits (lower limits as well as upper limits) on the size of the primary schools, that is no fewer than ten and no more than sixty students per grade level, in order to control the proliferation of tiny remote schools that are too small to be either academically or financially viable.
Few schools were too large for any meaningful learning to take place. On the other hand, more than forty schools had fewer than eighty students.
To adopt and implement a schedule of increasing subsidies to private schools to at least double the current amount over the next three years while making the subsidy contingent upon meeting minimum performance standards set by the Republic of the Marshall Islands government.
Subjecting public and private schools to the same standards should make both equally eligible to government support. In addition, subsidy support would make up for the anticipated loss or reduction in United States grant funds by way of textbooks and other instructional materials.
To make primary school attendance compulsory for children between the ages of 6 and 14 and restrict enrolment in primary schools to children of those ages. This goal was intended to overcome the ongoing problem where there was an extensive range in age among students at every grade level.
To postpone the development and operation of pre-school and kindergarten programs for a few years until the problems of the primary schools are substantially resolved and their performance substantially improved.
This goal considered the development of operation of pre-school programs less of a priority compared to the urgency needed to promote primary education. There was a perception that pre-schools require less complex management skills and therefore local communities could handle them for the time being.
(iii). Learning Achievements
Goals:
To focus special attention on the acquisition of fluency and literacy in both English and Marshallese.
This was essential in order to lay down a strong foundation of language skills necessary to prepare young children to comprehend, to express, and to understand concepts in all other fields of knowledge
To develop basic maths skills and a functional knowledge of basic science.
Acquisition of basic maths skills would prepare children to understand simple computational concepts useful for their academic learning in the middle and high school. Functional knowledge of basic science laid the foundation for later learning in high school and set the basis for children to explore the world of nature and the elements of other physical sciences.
To acquire basic understanding of the social and natural environment
Children would need to gain some understanding of the important elements in their own culture, its values, the Marshellese family and its values, and how society functions. They needed to gain basic understanding the type of natural environment that the Marshall islands has, the nature of island formation, the natural fauna and flora, and how the Marshallese people interacted and made a living (fishing) out this type of environment.
(iv). Adults Literacy
Goals :
To establish a national adult literacy programme aimed especially at the population group between 15 and 35 years of age, and to incorporate the necessary incentives necessary for adult achievement.
Creating a programme with a national scope would give the literacy initiative the necessary impetus. Restricting participation to this particular age group would ensure the involvement of a potentially active labour force.
To ensure that emphasis of the literacy national initiative is directed at the participation of women.
The goal would restore the current imbalance in the literacy rates between men and women. In addition it would highlight the importance of the mother as the first educator of the child.
To provide an adult literacy teacher training programme designed to provide teachers to instruct in the literacy programme.
A cadre of very well trained and highly motivated literacy teachers would ensure high rates of success.
To establish a number of adult literacy centres in selected islands with high population for the purpose of conducting literacy programmes.
Decentralising the literacy education process would ensure high level of involvement by those who were most in need of literacy learning.
To tie the literacy programme closely to local governments and to community-based social groups and non-governmental organisations, and to solicit their support in the management of literacy activities.
This would maximise the effective support of local institutions and grass-root social groups, who, for the most part, were working closely with young people and families at the community level.
(v) Skills
Overall the goals for skill development were:
To develop systematic vocational education that is integrated with academic learning and to co-ordinate such initiatives with other work related programs.
The idea was to make vocational training at the high school level capable of providing the basic academic learning desired as well as preparing the student for the employment market.
To provide a wide range training options in occupational skills to the young people who are vocationally inclined to enable them enter the job market and to become useful contributing member of the society.
A whole range of vocational options was necessary in order to meet the different skill needs of both the young people and the demand of the job market.
To create a national administrative entity that co-ordinates all vocational training in the Republic, maintain national standards, provide skill testing, monitors implementation of programs, liase with the employment sector, and issue certification.
The establishment of such a national entity would ensure that conflict in program offers were avoided, duplication eliminated, and quality of training carefully monitored and adhering to one national standard. Such an arrangement would ensure the efficient use of limited resources.
(vi). Quality of life
Goals :
To systematically explore the possibility of maximising benefits with respect to learning and training through the use of mass media including the use of cultural and traditional modes of idea dissemination.
The idea was to exploit all possible venues, which could contribute to the raising of the quality of life
To enhance the accessibility of the printed media including newspapers to outer islands by producing them in the local language.
The majority of those who were not always receiving the benefit of development must be brought into the process of national development.
To train Republic of the Marshall Islands educators in producing educational and training information using mass media as means for social change.
In order for the means for change to be effective those using them must also be trained in their use.
To encourage the local population, especially those from outer islands, to discuss their concerns and suggestions using the mass media channels.
The intention was to encourage local leadership and grassroots social and cultural groups to share their insights and concerns.
2.EFA Strategy and/or Plan of Action
Most of the important initiatives in the area of education in the Republic of the Marshall Islands were the sole responsibility of the Ministry of Education, both in terms of implementation and achievements of goals set. The Ministry of Education initiated a process of planning through the use of collaboration with other Ministries and Departments and non-governmental agencies where relevant. At this level overall major goals were set and appropriate policies were proposed for Government approval. Specific initiatives pertaining to specific areas of programs were allocated to those individual bureau or departments responsible. These were responsible for the direct managing and monitoring of activities in that area. Regular reviews of performance were then scheduled throughout the implementation period. Constraints were tracked down and remedies were instituted.
Over the years the Ministry of Education had conducted extensive collaboration with a number of international agencies in an attempt to achieve EFA national goals. Some of these agencies included UNESCO and other United Nations organisations, the Asian Development Bank and the Japanese Overseas Volunteers, US Peace Corp. and the Church Mission Support from Abroad.
Usually the Ministry of Education would appoint a Project Task Force mandated to monitor both the progress of the various initiatives and the use of necessary resources. In practice, one or more of the donor community members funded financial support for the creation of project implementation. The reviewing process was a joint enterprise comprising participating members of the donor community and officials of the Republic of the Marshall Islands. The Cabinet was regularly briefed and updated through the Minister of Education. Critically important national initiatives might result in administrative structuring of a certain component of the Ministry in order to make the necessary adjustment.
3. EFA Decision-Making and Management
Who decided on the formulation of a particular policy depended very much on the nature of that policy and its intended objective. For example, issues that had strong cultural bearings were bound to require the participation of a representative of the Council of the Chiefs. Issues with strong political connotations would likewise be submitted for due consideration of Cabinet, otherwise all policies which were strictly educational in objectives remained the responsibility of the Minister, Secretary of Education and, at times, the Under Secretaries. Other relevant and necessary information might be obtained from Heads of the various educational institutions and programmes. Educational matters concerning communities and outer island schools would involve consultation with Mayors, Marshall Islands Mayors Assn and local Government Councils.
Late last year the Ministry of Education established a National EFA Advisory Committee with members appointed from amongst high Government officials. Also established at the same time was the Technical Group drawn mainly from the Ministry of Education but with others from other Ministries including the Ministry of Planning, Internal Affairs and the University of the South Pacific Extension Centre. Two representatives are from non-governmental organisations, and more than 50% in this group are women. While the EFA Advisory Group met but once to be briefed over the basic concepts of EFA and their tasks, the Technical Group met several times, in which each member was assigned a specific task to perform and to report to the group in subsequent meetings. All members of this group are full-time employees, some from the Ministry of Education, others from different sectors or Ministries. However, all were willing to take time off to carry out their assignments.
4. Co-operation in EFA
National initiatives approved by Government normally receive maximum attention and co-operation from all Ministries and Government officials. There are, however, certain matters that could cause unnecessary delay - the retrieval of records and information ranks very high on the list.
This data gathering activity of EFA was taking place at the same time as the Republic of the Marshall Islands was in the middle of its population census. In addition, the Government was also active in the process of its tax reforms. All of these required the asking of questions within Ministries, agencies and households. Timing was very unfortunate as most of those with information were engaged in the implementation of these major projects.
Projects established:
Primary Education
- the establishment of an ADB funded National Teacher Training Programme based at the College of the Marshall Islands. This project was designed to provide training for as many teachers as possible in as short a time as possible. The project is still ongoing.
- the development of a National curriculum through a joint collaboration between subject specialists from abroad and officials of the Ministry of Education. The curriculum now awaits implementation until the relevant textbooks have been procured.
- The gradual decentralisation of a number of primary schools to local communities to be managed by local Governments, and this is a goal recommended in the Ten Year Master Plan. The Ministry of Education now focuses on the maintenance of standards in skill-testing activities, the evaluation of Primary school teachers and the provision of the necessary support for the maintenance of physical facilities. The decentralisation strategy is designed to empower local communities to be responsible for their own schools.
- The gradual introduction of computers to a number of schools where teachers are trained on their use and how to access information and where students can begin to become familiar with the use of technology prior to their high school education.
- The appropriation of funds to ensure a substantial upgrading or renovation of the physical facilities of all schools in the outer islands.
In implementing these EFA goals the Ministry of Education received assistance and support from a wide range of agencies.
The following agencies provided support and assistance in these ways:
UNESCO - financial support for the Youth to Youth Movement, the revival of cultural crafts and skills including canoe building; sponsoring numerous officials of the Ministry of Education and private organisations to educational workshops and seminars in the region including three EFA workshops this year; and visits by UNESCO officials to Marshalls to advise on a range of issues and on the EFA initiative.
Asian Development Bank - assisted in the funding of a number of national projects including teacher training programme and the development of the national curriculum.
Japanese Grants - funded the comprehensive multi building complex for the middle schools and the high school and providing Japanese vocational volunteers to help teach at the primary school in the areas of science and mathematics.
AUSAID - funded a wide range of capital projects and provided annually scholarships for Marshallese students to attend universities in the region. Funded a science project for primary schools and provided their own instructors to facilitate the project in a number of outer islands, also provided funds for improving electrification in a number of primary schools and funded computers for 5 primary schools.
UNIVERSITY OF THE SOUTH PACIFIC - through its Extension Centre in Majuro, collaborated with the Head Start management and the Minister of Education in setting up a teacher-training programme designed to prepare Head Start teachers in their careers.
SPBEA - which, through collaboration with the Ministrys National Bureau of Assessment and Evaluation, conducted over the past six years, annual testing of all Grade 4 students in Marshalls public primary schools.
NEW ZEALAND AID through its Regional Embassy in Kiribati expanded its scope of support on the provision of scholarships for Marshallese students to study in New Zealand. Seven students are currently studying in New Zealand universities.
THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT through its embassy in Suva funded the installation of a satellite dish to help Majuro radio broadcast BBC Education Programmes to the outer islands.
US PEACE CORP - up until 1995 the US Peace Corp were closely involved in helping promote education in the country, particularly in the area of teaching and administration.
5.Investment in EFA since 1990
Primary education derives its legal basis from the Constitution itself and so it commands a very favourable approval of Government so far as its financial support is concerned. Primary education in the Marshall Islands to date receives 10% of the GNP, an increase of about 2.5% over the 1991 appropriation. This 10% status has remained steady over the past three years and has given the sector of education a fairly stable basis for future planning and development. This figure includes the direct grants from the United States.
When the percentage of the Republic of the Marshall Islands operating budget appropriated to education is compared to the figure appropriated to education by other countries in the former Trust Territories, it becomes evident that RMI gives the lowest amount to education. For example, Kosrae FSM gives about 28%, Pohnpei FSM 22%, American Samoa 20%, and Yap FSM 18%.
Education receives a larger portion of the GNP than the Police and is on comparable level with the Ministry of Health. Both Ministries, however, receive a reasonably reliable level of funding through Federal Grants from the United States Government. Although public primary education is relatively cheap compared to private schools the imposition of progressive fees, beginning five years ago with the registration fee, indicates the Republic of the Marshall Islands desire for greater community sharing in the burden of education.
Funds from local sources are not sufficient even to cover personnel salaries, 20 % of which is met for through United States grants.
There is a tendency in the Marshall Islands that with respect to the use of donor funds a growing realisation is that core and essential programmes or any other national initiatives relating to human resources development must receive its funding support as far as possible from the Republic of the Marshall Islands Government. Donor funds are increasingly directed towards capital projects, including classroom resources and equipment.
The Republic of the Marshall Islands must inject the necessary guarantee to ensure that essential programmes are continued, even at the reduced level of operation. This strategy pertains to the Republic of the Marshall Islands determination to adhere to the principle of self-reliance implicit in the Education of 1991.
| Contents | Next Page |