|
Table of contents
Editorial
The First Three Years of MOST in Retrospect and Prospect
UNESCO's Management of Social Transformations (MOST) Programme
has just completed its third year of existence, having formally
launched its activities in March 1994. It was created with the
twin goals of (a) improving understanding by generating policy-relevant
knowledge, on three major issues of our time: multi-ethnic and
multi-cultural societies; cities; and local-global relatedness,
and (b) improving the communication between social researchers
and decision-makers. The Programme is steered by an Intergovernmental
Council and an independent Scientific Steering Committee. The
co-ordination is provided by a small secretariat co-ordinates
the Programme from the UNESCO Headquarters and national MOST Liaison
Committees (to this date established in 40 countries) relate the
Programme to national social science and policy communities.
Three busy years, devoted to the establishment and initiation
of MOST operations, began with an information campaign on the
Programme. Research and policy issues were mapped out, through
a series of regional and sub-regional consultative meetings between
social science researchers and representatives from the policy
communities in different regions of the world. Western Europe
and North America were covered through separate meetings: on multiculturalism
(Ottawa); on cities (Vienna); and on local-global issues (Paris).
Other thematic meetings were held in Tromsø (Norway) on
problems specific to circumpolar countries; in Helsinki on strategies
to develop MOST activities; in Roskilde (Denmark) on social development;
in Istanbul, during the HABITAT II Summit, on cities; in Frankfurt
on sustainability as a social science concept; in Costa Rica on
poverty and social exclusion; in Lausanne on governance; in Hong-Kong
and Tokyo on globalization and Asian mega-cities; and in Ankara
on social science and decision-making. Over this period, research
network workshops also took place as needed within the framework
of accepted MOST projects.
The Scientific Steering Committee evaluated 110 project proposals
and 20 comparative research networks (CRNs) were established to
work on the following issues:
- Monitoring Ethnic Conflict In Central And Eastern
Europe;
- Ethnicity And Conflicts In Africa;
- Citizenship And Multi-Culturalism In Europe;
- Democratic Governance In Multicultural Societies
In Central Asia;
- Migration And Ethno-Cultural Diversity In The
Asia-Pacific Region;
- Terminological Clarification For Multi-Cultural
And Multi-Ethnic Societies;
- Social Transformations And The Environment In
Cities;
- Socially Sustainable Cities;
- Urban Industrial Growth And Global Economy In
South Asia;
- Cities, The Environment And Gender;
- Growing Up In Cities;
- City Words: Speaking Of Cities;
- Strategies For Coping With Social Transformations
In Central And Eastern Europe;
- The Socio-Cultural Impact Of MERCOSUR Integration
In Latin America;
- Institutional Reform For Social Policies In Latin
America;
- Coping With Globalization In Circumpolar Regions;
- Social Transformations Associated With Drug-Trafficking;
- Globalization And Transformation In Rural Societies
In Arab Countries;
- Comparative Study Of The History Of National
Industrialization Policies;
- Sustainability And Sustainable Development Policies.
Representatives from the policy community were involved in the
planning of the projects with social scientists. The Programme
has both a Policy Paper and Discussion Paper series. Intermediary
results of the on-going project have started to be published.
In partnership with three research programmes in the natural
sciences - MAB, IHP and CSI -, the MOST programme injects a social
science dimension into several joint activities in ecology, hydrology,
coastal zones and small islands, urban governance, fresh water
resources, and socio-economic revitalization of historical city
centres.
An Internet MOST Clearing House was established for information
exchange. It now comprises specialized data bases on Best Practices
against poverty and exclusion and a discussion forum on ethical
issues in social science research. A thematic data base on multicultural
policies is underway as part of the expanding MOST Clearing House.
In addition to policy research, the MOST programme provides expertise
for the design of local plans of action to combat poverty and
social exclusion. Member States and United Nations Agencies and
Funds (UNDP, UNFPA) can thus draw on the Programme for increased
technical assistance in social policy planning.
The next four years will be devoted to ongoing work of the CRNs,
and new activities on international migration, population issues,
social exclusion and poverty, and urban development and governance.
A series of activities will be initiated in the complex area of
the relations between research and policy-making/decision-making.
This is an elusive subject, where real success stories need to
be coaxed out from research results. MOST activities in this field
will focus on case studies where social science research has
influenced policy, and on improving the transfer of social scientific
information to various users.
New UNESCO Chairs in MOST fields will be established to strengthen
social science teaching and research capacity, the first one having
been created in Etvös University, Hungary, on multi-culturalism
and minority problems. Young researchers will be provided with
first hand experience through training and involvement in research
projects and a MOST prize for outstanding PhD theses will be
operational as of 1998. Topical training modules for city professionals
on urban governance, as well as on poverty issues, and policy
evaluation methods will be designed.
The MOST Programme is basically a co-operative framework to contribute
to the promotion of high quality, policy-relevant, comparative
international social science research and to promote national
decision making through improved use of social science knowledge.
In a world where many of the social, economic, demographic, environmental
and technological processes have become transnational and global,
we believe this to be a useful undertaking.
Ali Kazancigil
Executive Secretary
MOST Programme
NEWS FROM MOST COMPARATIVE RESEARCH NETWORKS (CRN'S)
- NORAD funds GUIC Bangalore team
- Project network links to UNICEF's Child Friendly City
Initiative (CFCI).
- Averroes European Training Centre for Early Child Development
and the Family establishes training programme on GUIC for local
municipal planners. First 5 day training workshop: November 1997,
The Netherlands; Second workshop scheduled for June 1998.
A replication and extension of the original 1970s UNESCO Growing
Up in Cities Project, the goal of this project is to document
some of the human costs and benefits of economic development by
showing how the child's use and perception of the resulting micro-environment
affects his life and personal development. The microenvironment
in this case is urban neighbourhoods of young adolescents from
lower and working class backgrounds. The original UNESCO project
(ref: Growing Up in Cities, Kevin Lynch (ed.), M.I.T. Press,
1977) included research in such diverse settings as old city centres,
peripheral suburbs, high-rise blocks, and self-built settlements
in Australia, Argentina, Mexico and Poland. This project extends
the study to new sites in Africa, Asia and Norway, and revisits
some of the former sites in order to track how urban changes have
affected young people in the twenty years since the publication
of the original report.
Like the original project, this replication uses multiple methods:
observations of children´s use of public and semi-public
places; phenomenological measures of children´s perceptions
of their communities and their priorities for change and improvement;
and objective measures of their communities´economic, demographic
and environmental characteristics. It also compares childrens'
and parents' experience with municipal planners and officials'
assumptions regarding the effects of their policies on childrens'
lives. It adds new emphasis on childrens' participation in helping
to implement some of their recommendations for change, in keeping
with the application at the local level, of the UNICEF Convention
on the Rights of the Child, Agenda 21 of the Earth Summit and
the Habitat Agenda.
The project currently covers nine cities in seven countries (see
map). The project has raised support from UNICEF South Africa,
the HSRC of South Africa, NORAD, the Norwegian Ministry of Housing,
IDRC, the Buenos Aires labour union, the Johann Jacobs Foundation
and the Augusto Rancilio Foundation in the United States. Development
of this project has been made possible with the support of the
Norwegian Centre for Child Research in Trondheim Norway, and CHILDWATCH
INTERNATIONAL. An agreement is currently being signed between
the GUIC Buenos Aires team and its Mayor. N.A.
January-May 1997: all of the sites will conduct core environmental
observations and interviews and continue to develop plans for
the information´s dissemination and application. Communication
is maintained through internet
June 1997: Research leaders and coordinators will reassemble for
a workshop in advance of the Urban Childhood Conference in Trondheim
to discuss and approve the final contents of a manual for local
governance work with children growing up in big cities; to share
findings and co-ordinate presentations at the Conference; to identify
key indicators of childrens' experience of urban quality and to
discuss the development of a book composed of contributions from
each site
Summer-Spring 1998 will see emphasis on how the project´s
findings and processes are assimilated into local, regional, and
national planning initiatives and to turn results into publications
and presentation on the international and national level.
The project will be extended to Brasilia in 1998. Countries or
Cities interested in participating in the GUIC work are invited
to contact:
Averroès European Training Centre for Early Childhood Development and the Family invites GUIC to design and conduct five-day workshops for municipal planners.
First Workshop scheduled November 1997
The workshops draw on the experience gained by the GUIC team in
their seven-country study. They will focus on training planners
in participatory methods that enable collecting of basic information
from children in neighbourhoods and identifying their priorities.
These children thus become actors in the local decision-making
process, and learn to manage and monitor their places and environment.
The MOST training workshop will associate UNICEF's Child Friendly
City Initiative: For more information please contact: Nadia Auriat,
n.auriat@unesco.org
Childwatch International proposes to establish a
forum for people who would like to adapt GUIC methods to their
own settings. For more information on this please contact:
ASIA PACIFIC MIGRATION RESEARCH NETWORK
- Ministry of Education and Culture of Indonesia funds
national APMRN country team
- APMRN provides technical expertise to Meeting of Working
Group on International Migration, ACC Task Force on Basic Social
Services for All, February 1997, New York
- APMRN to participate in Technical Symposium on International
Migration, May 1998
- Australian APMRN country team holds national workshop,
April 1997
New Publications:
APMRN Working Papers Serie. Nº1. Migration Issues
in the Asia Pacific. APMRN Secretariat, University of Wollongong, Australia. UNESCO-MOST Paris. 1997
The network UNESCO-MOST APMRN researches and publishes trends
and developments in the population movements of the Asia Pacific
region. The working papers will be published regularly and aim
to provide reports on current research being undertaken by APMRN
members. Working Paper Nº 1 contains eleven papers, migration
and ethnocultural diversity; major policy issues; the state of
research on these themes; progress in establishing national research
networks to link up with the APMRN; key research themes for the
next five years; and, ideas on international research projects
and priorities. Papers cover these issues for New Zealand, Australia,
Fiji, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Malaysia, People's Republic of China,
Philippines, Republic of south Korea, Singapore and Thailand.
Available from: University of Wollongong, email: apmrn@uow.edu.au
or from the MOST Secretariat. N.A.
APMRN Research Papers Series
Aotearoa New Zealand
- Stephen Castles « Globalisation and the ambiguities
of national citizenship »
- Paul Spoonley « Migration and the Reconstruction of
Citizenship in Late Twentieth Century Aotearoa ».
These two papers were published together for the New Zealand APMRN
by the Deparment of Sociology, Massey University - Albany, Auckland.
The NZ APMRN is part of a local contribution to the international
MOST-APMRN network.
The Newzealand network contributes to the exchange of information between
research and policy analysis to advance understanding of what
is needed in terms of research as well as effective immigration
and post-migration policies in New Zealand.
« The debate about which migrants and how many has
been highly politicised in NZ history. The arrival of significantly
more East Asians since 1990 has attracted opposition and a new
period of anti-Asian sentiments. One notable aspect is the tendency
to favour emotion over facts, and to ignore some of the existing
research or available data on immigration. It has also highlighted
the need for considerably more research and more adequate policy
development. It is our ambition that the network might play a
role in helping contribute to both areas of development. »
Richard Bedford and Paul Spoonley, (from Introduction)
NA
Democratic governance in a multicultural and multi-ethnic society
- Swiss Government funds Democracy Training Programme for
Kyrgyzstan
At the request of the Kyrgyz Government a democracy training and
research project is underway to introduce policy-makers, legislators,
judiciary officials, and representatives from public and non-governmental
organizations from Kyrgyzstan to the functioning of democratic
governance under conditions of ethnic, linguistic and cultural
diversity.
The project is funded by the Swiss Government. Main activities
will be the establishment of an academic curriculum on democratic
governance, the training of legislators, academics and policy-makers
in the creation of laws concerned with multiculturalism, the publication
of basic texts on the subject, including comparisons of existing
approaches to the issues, and the establishment of an academic
exchange programme.
By developing institutional and individual ties with Switzerland,
leading Kyrgyz representatives will gain experience in building
and consolidating democratic structures founded on community-based
political participation and inter-ethnic co-operation. Swiss experts and institutions will benefit from sharing the
Kyrgyz experience of managing ongoing transformations. Short-term
training activities beginning this year are designed to lead to
long-term co-operation between the two countries, expected to
further the process of democratization in Kyrgyzstan.
The European Commission for Democracy through Law (the Venice
Commission) will contribute expertise to the training programme
in Kyrgyzstan. PdeG
MERCOSUR: Interaction and Integration
This MOST project, covering MERCOSUR countries (Argentina, Brazil,
Chile, Paraguay and Uruguay) will shed light on on societal mechanisms
that underlie the processes of dialogue among societies and cultures,
the basis of mutual respect and concern, and the structures and
institutions that may foster inter-cultural creativity. Given
the history and current manifestations of discrimination, cultural
warfare and xenophobia, the project is ultimately aimed at searching
for and putting into practice the means to foster solidarity,
understanding and full societal participation in the decision-making
process. C.M.
Project leader:
Elizabeth Jelin, University of Buenos Aires, Argentina
The MOST Programme and the UNESCO Office in Buenos
Aires organized the first MOST Symposium on Regional Integration
and Social Policy Reforms in Latin America (Buenos Aires,
20-22 November 1996). Latin American experts from projects MERCOSUR
and the « Institutional Modernisation of Social Policies
in Latin America », participated in the Symposium.
The network of participants in the project « Institutional
Modernisation of Social Policies in Latin America »
has finalized the four themes for its research agenda:
(1) education reforms;
(2) co-operation networks in the private sector;
(3) labour relations and
(4) political parties. National reports on
the situation of social policies for these sectors are being produced
respesctively for Argentina, Brazil, Chile and Mexico.
Social and Economic Transformations connected with Drug Trafficking
The development of the drug economy activity and its penetration
into the official sectors of society, seem to be causing a far
reaching shift in social patterns of development. The in-depth
study of these transformations is essential for decisionmakers
to define appropriate public management tools in the short,
medium and long terms.
The MOST project on "Social and Economic Transformations
connected with Drug Trafficking" gives prominence to research
conducted in five large countries or regions: Brazil, China, the Republics
of the former Soviet Union, South Asia and Nigeria. The project
will support the formation of teams in and on these areas. It
is foreseen to integrate three more teams respectively from India,
Mexico and Nigeria in 1998.
Project leaders: Michel Schiray, Centre National de la Recherche
Scientifique (CNRS), Groupement de Recherche « Psychotropes,
Politique et Société » (G 1106), France;
Christian Geffray Institut de Recherche Scientifique et Technique
pour le Développement en Coopération (ORSTOM), France
International Colloquium on the Situation
of Drugs in Sub-Saharan Africa April 1997
Warnings about the recent increase in drug cultivation, trafficking
and consumption in Africa were issued by field researchers, officials
and medical doctors at "The International Colloquium on the
Situation of Drugs in Sub-Saharan Africa", hosted by the
MOST Programme, and organized by the OGD (Observatoire Géopolitique des Drogues). Participants and speakers pointed out that this conference was probably among the first to address the entire drug chain from production to consumption. Among the various social and economic
factors that have contributed to Africa's drug crisis is the collapse
in agricultural produce prices. This has prompted peasants to
turn from legal cash crops to more profitable illegal drug production.
In the aftermath of the Colloquium, the MOST
project on "Social and Economic Transformations connected
with Drug-Trafficking" started preparing pilot activities
for 1997-1998. Different case-studies will be produced by researchers
from France, Brazil, China, India, Nigeria, Mexico and Germany. CM
Industrial decentralization and urban development in India
with consideration of South-east and East Asian cases
This MOST project was launched at a Workshop, held in September
1996, at the French Institute of Pondicherry. The aim of the
project is to examine simultaneously industrialization and urbanization
in the development of the following small and medium towns of
India and Sri Lanka: Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Tamilnadu, Maharashtra,
and the peripheries of Delhi and Colombo.
The French Institute of Pondicherry in its 23th issue of the « Pondy
Papers in Social Sciences », has published the
results of the workshop and main items of discussion on the research
project, contributions of participants and a general bibliography
on the statement of the problem.
Industrial decentralization and urban development. Véronique
BENEI et Loraine KENNEDY (eds.). Pondy Papers in Social Sciences,
No. 23, 1997. 165p. IFP (BP 33, Pondichéry 605 001 India).
G.S.
Community Networking in Polar Regions - CCPP
The Arctic Association of Sociology with the University of Tromsoe,
Norway organized the first CCPP workshop to launch pilot activities
related to coping strategies adopted by fishing, forest and mining
communities threatened by global change. The CCPP network studies
how changes due to globalisation may lead to new forms of community
co-operation, networking and collective action based on social
solidarity and traditions of mutual self-help. In April 1997,
the second CCPP Symposium at Roskilde University examined issues
related to community management of national resources, and socio-cultural
differences between arctic communities. Global economic, technological
and environmental forces provoke new constraints, but also opportunities
for local development and micro-level strategies. Two more meetings
are planned in 1997, one in the Faeroe Islands in June and a second
in Iceland in November.
Project Leaders: Nils Arsaether University of Tromsoe, Norway
and Jorgen Ole Baeraenholdt Roskilde University, Denmark
CM
Towards Sustainable Development
A three-day expert-workshop on the MOST project "Towards
sustainable development paradigm and policy: Sustainability as
a concept of social sciences", was organized by the "Institut
für sozial-ökologische Forschung" (ISOE) at Frankfurt,
from 20-22 November 1996. The meeting was to conclude the conceptual
phase of this research programme financed by the German Federal
Ministry for Research and Technology (BMFT). ISOE contracted
high-level resource persons from the social sciences (Argentina,
Austria, Brazil, Canada, China, France, Germany, India, Japan,
Netherlands, Nigeria, Pakistan, Russian Federation, Spain, UK,
and USA.) who attended a workshop and presented papers on the
status and perspectives of the debate on sustainable development.
The meeting gave rise to the adoption of a declaration; the constitution
of an international open-ended research network; and the production
of a synthetic document to be published as a MOST Policy Paper.
Furthermore, a publication on « Sustainability as a
Social Science concept » including the 16 expert reports
is foreseen for the end of 1997.
In order to promote social science research on sustainability,
exemplary research projects, especially in a cross-cultural and
comparative perspective, are to be sketched out. In this context,
a main concern should be the examination of policies adopted
by industrialised countries in order to contribute to global
change towards sustainable development strategies, especially
the impact of sustainability policies in the North in interaction
with the situation in the South.
Special attention should be paid to:
- studying the conditions under which people would alter non-sustainable
practices, implying research on opportunity structures that encourage
lifestyle change in the North (production and consumption patterns,
mobility etc.), while issues such as new clean energy sources,
food security or public transportation should be addressed with
respect to changes in the South. In addition, the role of industry,
finances, advertising, etc., as actors should also be analyzed.
- Investigating the influence of institutions at a local level
(community or local governance) on the (dis-) management of natural
resources, including the linkages to processes at other (nation-state)
levels.
- Analysing the issues raised with regard to the erosion of
the nation-state´s legitimacy and the simultaenous demands
on it to provide regulation in order to achieve sustainability,
understanding the linkages between national level sustainability
and international institutions or regulations in the context of
globalisation, especially with respect to issues like joint implementation,
but also to the shifting of unsustainability outside national
boundaries as well. CVF
The Cities Project: Where are we now?
The project "Cities: Management
of Social Transformations and the Environment" is now one
year old. It is developing as planned in three pilot sites: in
Yeumbeul, in the suburbs of Dakar, Senegal, in Port-au-Prince,
Haiti in fifteen shanty towns, and in Sao Paulo, Brazil.
In Yeumbeul, the partner associations
are: ENDA Tiers Monde and three community associations. Neighbourhood
development involving young people in the negotiation, planning
and construction of public street fountains, drainage wells, and
other community infrastructure projects involving women are among
the actions undertaken; UNDP, the European Union and the French
Mission for Co-operation have contributed financially to the actions
initiated by the project; a workshop summarizing these actions
was held in March 1997 bringing together 15 Mayors and representatives
of associations from Senegal, Mauritania, Burkina-Faso, Mali,
Cap Vert and Côte d'Ivoire who pledged to develop local
plans of action.
In Port-au-Prince, the partner associations
are: Research and Technology Exchange Group/ Haiti (GRET) and
SOLAM. Actions undertaken are those of improving the living conditions
of the inhabitants of 15 shanty towns, notably by setting up water
committees and public street fountains, and by providing skill
training for young people in the trade of plumbing.
In Sao Paulo, the partner associations
are Polis and the Instituto Florestal. An educational training
course for underprivileged young people was set up with the aim
of creating Eco jobs. G.D-C.
HABITAT II Aftermath
- In its final declaration, adopted unanimously, UNESCO proposed
to create an international prize "Mayors for Peace"
by which local authorities would be awarded for advancing the
"Culture for Peace" in their cities.
- The Dialogue on "Citizenship and Democracy in the 21st
Century", organized by UNESCO, issued three commitments that
Governments were asked to include in their actions for cities:
- consolidation of democracy;
- conditions of effective citizenship
- elaboration of a new social contract, founded on the promotion
of a humanized city, the exercise of all rights, beginning by
the right to housing, to participative citizenship, especially
that of women and the progress of civic culture.
- Priority areas of work for implementing the Habitat Agenda
at the local level are:
Promotion of sustainable urban development:
- foster productive employment and social integration
by encouraging positive interaction among culturally diverse
groups
- promote socio-cultural diversity in mega-cities and
towns.
- protect and maintain historic, cultural, social and natural
heritage of cities, including traditional shelter and settlement
patterns.
Enhance empowerment and participation to contribute to democracy
in urban society:
- encourage the establishment of community-based and civil
society organizations and other forms of non-governmental entities.
- Support initiatives and innovative experiences of citizens
especially youth and women
- Integrate a gender perspective in the design and implementation
of towns .
Promote education and training for major urban actors: urban professionals,
practitioners, politicians, civil servants, inhabitants mainly
in the following issues:
- training in traditional skills
- incentives for architects, planners, engineers and contractors.
- education for citizenship and democratic urban practices.
- strengthening of capacities of universities, training institutions
and NGOs.
Promote planning and good design in human settlements while emphasizing
aesthetic and social, as well as technical and functional qualities.
- Support research, studies and exchange of regional and international
experiences on housing and impacts of the built environment, on culture
and society.
- Enhancement and renewal of the revitalization and rehabilitation
of the social and socio-cultural heritage especially in inner
cities and neighbourhoods.
- Design of high-rise housing. Disaster prevention, mitigation,
preparedness and post-disaster rehabilitation capabilities.
- Sustainable energy use and new technologies for built-up environments. GS
MOST CLEARING HOUSE
The MOST Clearing House has started a Discussion Forum on the
Internet in which everyone interested in the MOST programme and
its projects is welcome to participate.
The purpose of the Forum is to animate a discussion on the general
themes of MOST.
The Forum can be found at the Web address of the MOST Clearing
House:
If you wish to receive announcements of the MOST programme activities
and new publications, send an e-mail message to:
In the body of the message, type the words subscribe most-list.
You will receive shortly thereafter an automatic acknowledgement
indicating that you have been added to the subscription list.
To stop your subscription, send a message to the same address
with the text unsubscribe most-list.
The publications, including the Newsletter that are announced
in the mailing list will usually be made directly available in
full text via the MOST Clearing House at: http://www.unesco.org/most PdG
Governance: What's in it?
The concept of governance is of relevance for a programme such
as MOST, which aims at linking social science research and policy-making.
Hence, an international Symposium was organized jointly by MOST,
the University of Lausanne and the Swiss National Commission for
UNESCO (Lausanne, Switzerland, 29-30 November 1996). It brought
together about 20 scholars from Europe, USA, Mexico and India,
to explore the much-used (and abused) concept of governance from
theoretical as well as practical/functional perspectives.
Governance is often utilized as a synonym of government, which
the discussions of the Symposium demonstrated to be incorrect.
Unlike government, governance is not characterized by specific
structures, but rather a series of procedures and practices, which
distinguish it from the traditional forms of government. It does
not replace, but is complementary to the latter. It initially
started in the city management context, and it still is at its
best as a local and sectoral policy-making mechanism. It also
fits well the world scene, as global governance, applied to issues
such as peace-building, human rights or the environment, where
there is an absence of hierarchical authority and law enforcement,
and where particular issues are negotiated between specific groups
of stake-holders (in this case, sovereign states and international
organizations), a situation quite typical of governance.
The governance approach has attracted attention at the national
level since the 1980s, in the context of the so-called governability
crisis, as an efficient policy-making method, better suited than
the traditional, hierarchical mode of government, to the complexity
of issues and plurality of public and private stake-holders participating
in decision-making. Indeed, given the increased uncertainties
and risks in modern societies, policy-making requires increased
state-society interactions and horizontal co-ordination between
multiple social agents, such as public administrations, private
firms, professional and voluntary associations, labour unions,
« green » movements, etc. Thus, governance
which allows such interaction appears as the appropriate process
for negotiation, accommodation and policy-making on specific sectoral
or local issues. It is all the more attractive that it is democratic,
participatory, and accountable to the stake-holders. The efforts
towards a leaner and more efficient state and local government
in Western countries were generally inspired by this approach.
International organizations, such as the World Bank and UNDP,
encouraged institutional reforms of this kind in the countries
of the South.
Yet, the mode of governance, suitable as it is for policy-making
at the local and global levels, proved to be more problematic
at the nation-state level. Indeed, policy-making between stake-holders
forming a « policy community » serves the
purpose of solving specific sectoral problems, without necessarily
taking into account the interests of society as a whole. Public
administrations participate in horizontal negotiations as one
stake-holder among others, focusing on the sectoral issues and
relinquishing their function of servicing the general interest.
This amounts to a « privatisation » of public
authority, which loses its distinct political status. Governance
can end up being a procedure through which certain decisions are
excluded from the normal process of democratic, representative
politics. It cannot replace long-term, trans-sectoral policies
for nation-wide issues such as employment, urban and educational
issues. Choices about an equitable allocation of societal resources
amongst all citizens belong to the realm of democratic politics,
whose rationality is distributive and whose finality is equity,
solidarity and freedom, before instrumental concerns such as efficiency.
In conclusion, governance is a form of policy-making complementary
to traditional government, and should be subsumed under representative
democratic politics. AK
Based on: Ali Kazancigil, « Governance and Science:
Market-like Modes of Governing Society and Producing Knowledge »
to appear in International Social Science Journal, no.155,
March 1998.
News from National Liaison Committees
The Tanzanian National Liaison Committee organized a workshop
from 18 to 19 March 1997 on urban migration and environment:
the case of Dar-Es-Salaam City.
The Croatian National Liaison Committee is carrying out a 1996/1997 MOST project "Multiculturalism and
Post-Communism, Tradition and Democratic Processes" as a fourfold study comprising the following sub-projects:
- Historical Framework for the Breakdown of Communism: Problems
of Inheritance in the Process of Re-establishing Democratic Societies:
analyzes changes in the Croatian society within the new historical
and social framework of post-communism. One of the ongoing activities
was a research focus on Social Transformations in Post-Communism
and the Problem of Multiculturalism, that appraised changes
in the interpretation of multiculturalism. This was carried out
in co-operation with the Institute for Post-Communist Society,
Kiev, Ukraine and involved an expert meeting organized in Kiev
in June 1996 (Project Director: Mr. Mislav Kukoë, Institute
for Applied Social Research, Zagreb).
- Southeast European Multicultural and Multiethnic Societies,
Democratic Changes and Development Prospects deals with the
structure of public institutions within newly emerging multicultural
and multiethnic societies and states (Project Director: Ms. Nada
Svob-Dokic, Institute for International Relations, Zagreb).
- Intercultural Orientations and Relations in Education,
Media and Business analyzes relevance of different school
programmes, media and other channels of communication and education
for the development of intercultural understanding and communication
(Project Director: Ms. Zlata Godler, Faculty of Philosophy, University
of Zagreb).
- Political Changes, Reinvention of Tradition and Transmission
of Multiculturalism using anthropological approaches
and qualitative methodology, analyzes the relation between tradition
and democracy in the re-creation of identities for both cultural
majority and minority groups in Croatia (Project Director: Ms.
Vedrana Spajic-Vrkas, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Zagreb).
MOST TECHNICAL COOPERATION
JOINT UNICEF, UNESCO-MOST, UNDP, UNCHS, UNEP and PLAN International meeting on African Child Friendly Cities
11-13 March 1996
The Accra Metropolitan Assembly, UNICEF, and UNCHS/Habitat convened
on 11-13 March 1997 an International Workshop on Africa's Urban
Poor Child in partnership with the Urban Management Programme
(UMP), the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), the United
Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), the United Nations Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO -MOST Programme),
and PLAN International.
Objectives of the workshop:
To explore policy options and develop recommendations for African
Mayors to commit themselves to the plight of the African urban
poor child; and 2) to develop strategies on implementing "The
Convention on the Rights of the Child" at the local level,
through the development and implementation of municipal or local
plans of action.
Call for African Mayors and Local Authorities for Building
Child-Friendly Cities
The mayors' deliberations were presented to participants during
the closing plenary in the form of a "Call for Mayors
and Local Authorities for Building Child-Friendly Cities".
The document calls for all African mayors and local authorities
to develop local plans of action that promote the building of
child-friendly cities on the continent. Amongst other issues,
the document recommends:
1) the ratification of the African Charter
on the rights and well-being of the child as adopted by the Organization
of African Unity (OAU, 1990);
2) the establishment of birth registration
programmes and local censuses of children desegregated by age,
gender, and by geographical location;
3) the organization of child
and family development committees that include children and youth;
4) the improvement and protection of the urban environment, creating
urban green areas, play areas and promoting innovative waste disposal
and recycling methods at the community level;
5) the creation
of an African secretariat of mayors to monitor inter-agency local
implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child at
the municipal level.
Mayors, Local Authorities, Technical Municipal Staff, and Local
Governance Institutions as Orchestrators and Co-ordinators of
Local Plans of Action and Child-Centred Partnerships
Mayors in this workshop took on an expanded role in the defence
of children. A new role that Mayors assigned to themselves, during
the Accra Workshop's initial deliberations, was to actively monitor
the compliance to childrens' rights within their territories.
The workshop has also demonstrated that activities in favour of
child well-being should and can be undertaken through a multi-agency
participatory process aimed at taking stock of progress and commitments
for urban children, and triggering future action at all levels.
The workshop made clear that a single framework for action - linking
the Convention of the Rights of the Child, the Habitat Agenda
and Agenda 21 - for the implementation of Local Plans of Action
in favour of vulnerable children and women is possible. Furthermore,
it was a positive workshop of a new style.
UNESCO-MOST, in co-operation with the UNICEF Urban Section, other
UN agencies and partners, is planning to organize a workshop on
Education for Local Governance for the African region in 1999
as follow-up to the Accra initiative.
NA
Cape Verde
A National Programme for the Fight against Poverty has been funded
under the UNESCO Participation Programme in cooperation with the
UNDP and the World Bank. The MOST Programme is a partner in discussions
underway on the policy, strategies and plans for health, education
and population policies.
C.M.
UNESCO Chairs
To ensure effective complementarity in capacity-building, the
UNITWIN/UNESCO Chairs programme has been called upon to set up
joint MOST Chairs. A first MOST Chair focusing on Minority Studies
was launched at Lorand Eötvös University (ELTE), at
Budapest, Hungary, in January 1997. The purpose of the programme
is to focus on the reduction of ethnic tensions and conflicts.
Another step towards the establishment of a UNESCO Chair on Social
Transformations has been recently taken by the Azerbaidjanian
National Commission for UNESCO who wish to build a centre of excellence
in the social sciences
KNOWLEDGE AND POLICIES FOR SUSTAINABLE COASTAL DEVELOPMENT
ESSAOUIRA : An Integrated Urban Development and
Water Ressource Project
January 1996 marked the beginning of the UNESCO programme on
Environment and Development in Coastal Regions and Small Islands
that provided a platform for a new project run jointly by the
Division of Water Sciences and the Human Habitat Unit from the
Social Science Sector. The project, entitled Urban Development
and Freshwater Resources in Coastal Areas follows the
recommendations made in the Agenda 21 action plan, Habitat II
and the World Summit for Social Development. Its mandate lies
in respecting environmental and economic concerns for the development
of small coastal cities of Europe and the Southern Mediterranean.
The creation of a network of co-operating coastal cities promotes
the sharing of expertise and specialists in such diverse areas
as freshwater management, revitalisation and renovation of urban
historic fabrics, economic and social development, coastal erosion
and environmental protection.
The first case study for this project is the historic town of
Essaouira, Morocco, on the Atlantic coast, approximately one thousand
kilometres from Gibraltar. This site, know in the past as Mogador,
was an ancient trading port, the construction of which was entrusted
to Theodore Cornut -a student of Vauban - in the mid XVIII°
century, the old walled Medina has been for long considered a
cross-road and meeting point of cultures and civilizations. Its
history and architectural context remind the onlooker of the fortified
city of Saint Malo, designed by Vauban. In a day and age of accelerated
transformation, Essaouira represents a cultural and historic patrimony
that is a valuable reminder of our civilization's rich and intricate
past. In keeping with this observation, Morocco's National Authorities
have requested that the ancient town be placed on the World Heritage
List.
Today a town of 80,000 inhabitants, Essaouira's problems are
numerous: overpopulation, building deterioration and insufficiency
of infrastructure, coastal erosion and salt-water intrusion combine
to put pressure on its sustainability. Particularly afflicted
are the city's ancient wall and its two historic Italian monuments
(Scalas) on the port.
An identification mission was undertaken to Essaouira early 1997.
A joint experts, donors and local authority meeting is planned
for december 1997. For more information on this project, please
contat: Ms. Brigitte Colin, Architect, UNESCO Human Habitat Unit,
b.colin@unesco.org
Essaouira: An Urban Wonder of Tradition and Modernity
Photo Pierre Gailhanon
RECENT MEETINGS
MOST-UNU workshop on globalization and mega-city development
in Pacific Asia
Tokyo in October 1996.
The MOST Programme and the United Nations University, through
its Institute of Advanced Studies, organized a workshop covering
a selected number of study-cases, from Bombay, Bangkok, Hong Kong,
Jabotabek, Manila, Seoul, Shanghai, Singapore and Tokyo, with
emphasis on urban policy for housing, environmental protection,
transportation, migration, social exclusion, poverty, public finance,
forms of co-operation between the central government and local
authorities, and other social and economic actors who participate
in city governance.
The workshop was funded by Japan as funds-in-trust for UNESCO-UNU
co-operation. Planning is underway to continue with a series of
regional workshops on urban and social issues to be held in Africa
and Latin America. GS
Sub-Regional Consultation for
English-speaking Caribbean Countries
Kingston, Jamaica, 24-26 February 1997
This MOST subregional meeting, opened by the Jamaican Minister
of Education, Youth and Culture, highlighted the themes of multi-ethnic
power-sharing and Caribbean capacity for social science research
in the fields of MOST. A strong emphasis was put on the need for
academic co-operation in joint projects that address issues pertinent
to the region, notably, tourism, economic co-operation, urbanization
and migration. Following the Conference, a project focusing on
crime and violence in the city, population shifts and patterns
of migration, social exclusion and possibilities of integration
will be developed. A full report of the meeting and several of
the presented papers are available from the MOST Clearing House
at http://www.unesco.org/most/carib.htm or in printed form from the MOST
secretariat. PdG
UPCOMING MEETINGS
Forms of Exclusion
23-26 June 1997
The MOST Programme is organizing, in close collaboration with
the University of Pittsburg and the Université de Paris-VII,
an International Colloquium on Different Forms of Exclusion. at
UNESCO Headquarters, on 23-26 June 1997. Exclusion of women,
writers, the poor and the ill are given particular attention during
these 4 days. CM
Partnerships for Urban Policies
24-25 November 1997
On 24 and 25 November 1997, MOST is organising, in association
with the International Social Science Council, a Colloquium on
the theme « Partnerships for Urban Policies ».
Tunis: Regional Cultural Capital for 1997
UNESCO and the Association for Saving the Medina:
"Social Revitalization of an Old Quarter"
2nd Conference of World Heritage Cities
December 1997
As part of the follow-up activities of the Human Habitat Unit
begun during HABITAT II Conference, the Division for Social Sciences,
Research and Policy launched a programme "Revitalizing Urban
Centres". It is composed of pilot projects in town centres
where communities' living conditions need upgrading while preserving
both architectural and cultural identities and continuing traditional
social activities. BC
World Social Science Report
The twentieth century has seen extraordinary advances in the social
sciences. They have taken place at the level of theoretical constructs,
but also at the levels of methodology and of data generation and
management. The social sciences can now be regarded as comprising
a fabric of concepts and testable theories, rapidly expanding
pools of records and information, well-established rules of procedure,
and world-wide networks of supporting institutions.
With the approach of the turn of the century, the time is ripe
to take stock of the social sciences as they are, and to look
forward to their continuing development in the coming decades.
This, essentially, is the goal of UNESCO's projected World
Social Science Report. It is planned to bring out a first
issue in 1999, in time to be available for the World Science Conference,
and subsequent issues at intervals of, say, two years.
The World Social Science Report will benefit from the experience
of reports already created by UNESCO in other areas, in particular,
the World Education Report and the World Science Report.
It will be in part problem-oriented, looking at their applications
to practical problems in the world today; in part descriptive,
giving information on the production and transmission of the social
sciences in the countries of the world; in part substantive,
reviewing the state of play in the various social sciences; and
in part reflective, considering the place of the social
sciences in the worlds of knowledge and of action. DM
Social Science Participation in the World Science Conference
UNESCO is organizing, for the autumn of 1999, a major international
conference on the state of science in the world, its role in human
affairs, and the prospects for its further development and applications
in the coming century.
It has been agreed that in the preparation of this important World
Science Conference, the concept of "science" will be
understood in a broad sense, so that in effect the conference
will concern an extended range of sciences, ranging from mathematics,
through physics, chemistry and other "exact", "natural"
and life sciences, to the social sciences.
For this reason, the Sector of Social and Human Sciences of UNESCO
is urging the inclusion of top-flight representatives of the
disciplines in both the Conference itself and in the preparatory
bodies. It is also preparing, as an input to the Conference, a
World Social Science Report, the first of its kind (see
adjacent feature).
It is expected that the Conference will render more visible, via
the media to the general public, as well as to specialists themselves
engaged in scientific activities, the intricate connections between
the scientific disciplines, bridging the social sciences with
others, on a number of levels levels, such as that of collaboration
in the solution of problems where several disciplines are involved;
the social factors involved in the human use of the technologies
issuing from scientific discovery; and also the social and cultural
conditions favouring and impeding scientific investigation and
creativity. DM
MOST Secretariat:
e-mail: ssmost@unesco.org
Executive Secretary
Director, MOST Newsletter:
ALI KAZANCIGIL
Editor, MOST Newsletter
Multi-cultural and multi-ethnic societies and
Programme on Application of Research to Policy:
NADIA AURIAT
e-mail: n.auriat@unesco.org
Publications:
DAVID MAKINSON
Clearing House/Capacity Building:
PAUL DE GUCHTENEIRE
PETRA VAN VUCHT TIJSSEN
Sustainable Development and Training:
CHRISTINA VON FURSTENBERG
Cities and Human Habitat:
GENEVIEVE DOMENACH-CHICH
Cities and Urbanization:
GERMAN SOLINIS
Cities and Architecture:
BRIGITTE COLIN
Women in Development:
MARIA LUISA NITTI
Multi-cultural and multi-ethnic Societies:
JUAN DIEZ MEDRANO
Coping locally and regionally with economic,
technological and environmental phenomena
and MOST Liaison Committees:
CARLOS S. MILANI
Requests for MOST Documentation:
CATHERINE BAUER
Senior Secretary:
MARIA J: GUTIERREZ
Layout and printing:
EGOPRIM
National MOST Liaison Committees and UNESCO National Commissions
are invited to submit to the Editor information on national MOST
activities for publication in upcoming editions of the Newsletter.
Ministries, NGOs, research councils, research institutions,
universities and other UN Agencies working with social science
research projects may send information to the Editor for diffusion
in this publication.
This publication is distributed to Universities, Research Councils,
Development Agencies and UN Agencies world-wide. It appears in
English, French and Spanish.
|
|